Stories

Case narratives documenting individual sentencing and reoffense outcomes.

September 17, 2026
150 Arrests Later, NY Bail Law Frees Shaquan Seth Again

Shaquan Seth, arrested nearly 150 times, walked free without bail twice in ten weeks before a Queens judge finally set bail after his third arrest.

150 Arrests Later, NY Bail Law Frees Shaquan Seth Again
September 16, 2026
Brooklyn Judge Robinson Freed Repeat Offender Wilkinson. He Shot a Man at the Parade.

Nayshawn Wilkinson, 19, was released on $5,000 bail by Brooklyn Judge Janice Robinson despite an attempted murder charge, then shot another man at the West Indian Day Parade five weeks later. He is one of thirteen recent defendants the judge has released on no bail or reduced bail.

Brooklyn Judge Robinson Freed Repeat Offender Wilkinson. He Shot a Man at the Parade.
September 5, 2026
Jose Rodriguez Was on Probation When He Went on a Stabbing Spree

A man with a stabbing conviction and six parole violations was on probation, not in prison, when he allegedly moved through Oakland's Fruitvale neighborhood for half an hour, killing one man and stabbing four others.

Jose Rodriguez Was on Probation When He Went on a Stabbing Spree
September 2, 2026
Serial “Butt Sniffer” Calese Crowder Arrested Again in California

Calese Crowder, the repeat offender dubbed the “Butt Sniffer,” has been accused of the same act at five different Southern California stores in five years; the state's cumulative answer has been 264 days in county jail.

Serial “Butt Sniffer” Calese Crowder Arrested Again in California
August 18, 2026
Repeat Offender Fale Pea Blinds 75-Year-Old Seattle Woman

Repeat offender Fale Pea, freed by a lenient 2012 sentence and a 2025 wave of dismissed charges, randomly blinded 75-year-old Jeanette Marken in Seattle.

Repeat Offender Fale Pea Blinds 75-Year-Old Seattle Woman
August 13, 2026
California Freed a Double Murderer. He Killed Again in Under a Year

A California parole board overruled prosecutors' objections and freed Darryl Collins, a two-time murderer, in 2020. Fatima Johnson paid for that decision with her life 364 days later.

California Freed a Double Murderer. He Killed Again in Under a Year
August 12, 2026
Freed on $2,500 Bond, Charged With Murder 16 Days Later

A federal magistrate released Ashlie Jeremie on unsecured $2,500 bond over prosecutors' objection, and sixteen days later he was charged with beating Jonathan Sanon to death near Boston Common and attacking a college student blocks away.

Freed on $2,500 Bond, Charged With Murder 16 Days Later
August 11, 2026
California's Catch-and-Release System Let Him Go Twice. Todd Stewart Paid With His Life

A Contra Costa County judge released Marcos Iriarte-Valdez on his own recognizance one day before he allegedly stabbed 68-year-old Todd Stewart to death outside his Martinez home.

California's Catch-and-Release System Let Him Go Twice. Todd Stewart Paid With His Life
August 3, 2026
Sentence Cut in Half, Then Gunfire on Memorial Drive

Tyler Brown, a career criminal with a three-decade violent record, should never have been free to walk Memorial Drive that afternoon. He got a fraction of the prison sentence prosecutors requested in 2021, then used his freedom five years later to open fire on a crowded Cambridge street, shooting Casimir Bangoura and another driver a block from Harvard's campus.

Sentence Cut in Half, Then Gunfire on Memorial Drive
Updating…